Listen to the new album by Elias Dummer!
Listen to the new album from Elias Dummer!

JFH Staff Review


mewithoutYou, Pale Horses
CLICK COVER TO ENLARGE

mewithoutYou
Pale Horses

Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Indie
Album length: 11 tracks: 39 minutes, 20 seconds
Street Date: June 16, 2015


READER RATING:   


I admit that, going into this album, I was not a big fan of mewithoutYou's unique music style. Some of the spoken/sung vocals and extremely complex lyrics seemed strange and slightly off-putting at first. But earlier this year, I decided to give their album Brother, Sister a listen, and their signature sound slowly grew on me. So I went into Pale Horses with a better understanding and appreciation of the band's artistic and poetic approach. All that said, Pale Horses is very impressive, though maybe not for everyone.

After the slightly uninteresting intro/title track, the album sets the tone with "Watermelon Ascot," a somewhat aggressive and almost hard rock number that serves as an in-your-face, thoughtful opener, and my personal favorite on Pale Horses. The album then transitions to the more somber and reserved "D Minor," with poignant lyrics dealing with failed relationships: "From the frying pan of a celibate man, to the fires of the premature/Who could ask for nothing more?" "Mexican War Streets" is another highlight that starts off slow with clean guitar and soothing vocals, but builds into more intensity toward the end as the lyrics get more spiritual: "I'd like to meet Whoever said the words we print in red". Following that is "Red Cow," a musical roller coaster that expertly transitions from softer guitars, vocals, and driving drums in the verses to distorted riffs and loud yelling vocals in the "choruses" that feel like it imitates the ups and downs of life. The midpoint of the album then brings us to the intermission track, "Dorothy," which is lyrically strange and awkward.

The second half of the album begins with "Blue Hen," an excellent, groovy, and melodic indie rock song that speaks about victory over death: "Death where is thy sting? You ought to put more thought into what you bravely sing/Aft-mast ships of straw-short bricks/You'll soon see exactly where my victory is." "Lilac Queen" is a solid song, but probably one of the weakest on the album due to its somewhat incoherent musical styles and overly cryptic lyrics. The acoustic guitar driven "Magic Lantern Days" is a nice change of pace, if not a bit repetitive vocally. Drawing us closer to the end of the album is "Birnam Wood," a contemplative tune with upbeat drums, a catchy guitar riff, and deep lyrics about questioning God's plan: "Steady is a knife held sure by faith/Are you a God? And shall Your grace grow weary of Your saints?" Bringing the album to a close is "Rainbow Signs," a unique, musically rich, but slightly overlong piece with poetic and apocalyptic lyrics (in English and Aramaic) that possibly reference the end of the world: "The sky, I'd been told, would roll up like a scroll/As the mountains and islands move from their place."

In conclusion, I think this is a fantastic album, but don't expect the most polished Christian album this time around. "D Minor" contains the word "b*stard" in negative context, and "Rainbow Signs" possibly uses a muted "F" word, but it's a bit unclear. Also, a weakness of this album is that it suffers from being too poetic lyrically at times, even to the point of being downright confusing occasionally. But, musically, it is consistently impressive, intricate, and even beautiful. Pale Horses is a wonderful addition to any mewithoutYou fan's library, as well as any fan of thought provoking music if you're willing to take the time to dig into it to find the gems.

JFH Reader Review: Review date: 11/10/15, written by Dylan O'Connor for Jesusfreakhideout.com


Get the new book by Tanner Olson!

 

. Record Label: None
. Album length: 11 tracks: 39 minutes, 20 seconds
. Street Date: June 16, 2015
. Buy It: iTunes
. Buy It: Amazon.com
. Buy It: AmazonMP3

  1. Pale Horse (2:26)
  2. Watermelon Ascot (3:08)
  3. D-Minor (3:19)
  4. Mexican War Streets (3:34)
  5. Red Cow (3:59)
  6. Dorothy (1:39)
  7. Blue Hen (3:05)
  8. Lilac Queen (3:58)
  9. Magic Lantern Days (3:52)
  10. Birnam Wood (4:17)
  11. Rainbow Signs (6:03)

 



Leave a Comment

comments powered by Disqus

 

 

go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive

 


(JFH Sponsor Spot)

 

 

           
Get the new book by Tanner Olson!

Search JFH



This Friday, September 25, 2020
Landry Cantrell Glasshouse [DREAM]
Natalie Grant No Stranger [Curb/Word]
Coby James Infinite - Single [Centricity]
Bryon Juane Promise I'm Not Crazy EP [RMG]
KB His Glory Alone [HGA/Essential Sound]
Tasha Cobbs Leonard Royalty: Live At The Ryman [Motown Gospel]
Jessy Elsa Palma Jehovah - Single [Integrity]
Mr. Talkbox Playlist (independent)
PEABOD Wonderful & Scary - Single [Centricity]
Sarah Reeves Motions - Single [Curb/Word]
Slick Shoes Rotation & Frequency [Tooth & Nail]
WHATUPRG New Hollywood [Reach]


Next Friday, October 2, 2020
Josh Baldwin Evidence [Bethel Music]
Fireflight Who We Are - Single [Rockfest]
Jason Gray Reorder - EP [Centricity]
Kirk Franklin and the Family Christmas Vinyl Re-release [RCAI]
The Nelons Peace At Last [Daywind]


For all release dates, click here!
 



Listen to the new children's album from The Block Worship!




Listen to the new album from Radio Friendly!